Welcome to Pagliai's Pizza
At Pagliai's Pizza, we pride ourselves on crafting unforgettable dining experiences right in the heart of Charleston, Illinois. Our story begins with a passion for authentic Italian cuisine and a commitment to using only the freshest ingredients. Whether you crave our signature double thick crust or a light, thin crust topped with premium sausage and vibrant vegetables, each slice delivers exceptional flavor. Our warm, inviting atmosphere, complete with a touch of elegance, makes it ideal for family dinners or casual gatherings. We invite you to taste the best pizza in town, where every meal is a celebration of tradition and quality.
Pagliai's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Delicious pizza!! Got a thin crust with sausage and veggies and it was very good. Light and delicious. Also got a salad with house dressing, salad was nothing special but the dressing was so good! Dipped my pizza in it as well.
I havent actually dined in, although the inside is how i feel Italian places should be, darkish. Just wish there was more seclusion between booths. ...
We were in town for a middle school basketball game and decided to try Pagliais. It did not disappoint! Unlike the game... The atmosphere was great. However, the lighting was a bit dim for my taste but ...
Best pizza in town. They have different crust options, but I prefer the double thick crust. Toppings and sauce always taste fresh. They are lightning fast for pickup. The House Special is double sausage, double cheese, double thick ...
My favorite pizza!!!! So muchyummy. The sausage is the best Ive ever had.
The set up in this little place is super cute. You can watch them make pizza as you dine. If you go at Night prepare to eat in a very dim dining room. I had to use my ...
I think heaven will smell like Pagliais pizza. Our family loves the House Special and the Pancho Villa with sausage instead of ground beef.
Its been 40 years since I last had a pizza here! Exactly as I remember it the Pagliais Special is delicious Friendly staff and great service. For a Monday night, the place was busy, which is always a good sign. ...
Location
-
1600 Lincoln Ave, Charleston, IL 61920 Hotline: (217) 345-3400
Welcome to the delightful world of Pagliai's Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Charleston, Illinois. Located at 1600 Lincoln Ave, this charming pizzeria invites you to experience pizza in a whole new light. Renowned for its delectable offerings and inviting atmosphere, Pagliai's Pizza stands as a beacon for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike.
As you step inside, you're greeted by a cozy yet classy ambiance. The low lighting adds a touch of intimacy, making it an ideal spot for family dinners or casual gatherings. The décor sets the mood, reminiscent of authentic Italian pizzerias, yet with a casual undertone that makes you feel right at home. While the atmosphere is relaxing, it does cater to a vibrant dining experience, making it perfect for groups.
What truly sets Pagliai's Pizza apart is its variety of crust options and fresh toppings. Customers rave about the thin crust and the beloved double thick crust, which has earned a dedicated following. For those who enjoy bold flavors, the House Special—featuring double sausage and double cheese—is a must-try. Diners appreciate the freshness of the ingredients, ensuring each bite bursts with flavor. As one satisfied customer, Tommy Mac, aptly put it, “Best pizza in town.”
- Customer Favorites: The sausage, noted for being the best ever tasted, is often highlighted in reviews, appealing to meat lovers.
- Environmental Features: Dogs are welcome, and outdoor seating is available, enhancing the dining experience for pet owners and nature enthusiasts alike.
- Quick Service: Patrons can count on lightning-fast service for takeout, making this a convenient option for busy families.
The menu doesn’t stop at pizza. Guests can pair their meal with a refreshing salad drizzled with a delicious house dressing—perfect for dipping your pizza crust! Additionally, Pagliai’s Pizza accommodates groups and offers catering, making it an excellent choice for celebrations and gatherings.
What truly shines through in the reviews is the community feel of Pagliai's Pizza. Whether you're a local or just passing through for a middle school basketball game, this pizzeria is more than just a place to eat; it’s a hub of joy where families and friends come together over their love for pizza. With credit cards accepted, on-site parking, and free Wi-Fi, every detail ensures your visit is enjoyable.
If you're craving a taste of pizza perfection, look no further than Pagliai's Pizza. Grab your friends, bring your family, and prepare to indulge in one of Charleston's favorite culinary destinations!
For inquiries or to place an order, don’t hesitate to call them at (217) 345-3400.
